Least effective
Most effective
0

No Protection

The device offers no designed-in protective features. Exposure to the hazard cannot be avoided through skill or technique; it can only be minimised through PPE.

Examples
  • –Manual spray painting without ventilation. The operator will inhale fumes during use, regardless of technique.
  • –Welding without a screen. The operator will be exposed to UV radiation during use, regardless of technique.
1

Safe Only With Correct Use

The device offers no designed-in protective features, but the hazard can be avoided entirely through correct skill and technique.

Examples
  • –A basic chainsaw. Safety depends entirely on operator technique, stance, and PPE (chaps, helmet, gloves).
  • –A tube-style belay device. The device has no automatic braking. Safety depends entirely on the belayer maintaining proper grip and technique.
  • –A knife. No guards or safety features, but proper technique makes it safe to use.
2

Safety Encouraged

The device has designed-in cues, markings or warnings to encourage correct behaviour, but does not block unsafe use.

Examples
  • –An extension ladder with angle indicators, "this side up" labels, and anti-slip feet. These cues guide correct setup, but nothing prevents the operator from ignoring them.
  • –A medication bottle with a warning label and dosage instructions. The guidance is clear, but nothing prevents the user from ignoring it.
  • –Electrical wiring with colour-coded insulation. The colours guide correct connections, but nothing prevents crossing wires.
3

Safety Assisted

The device has designed-in features that prevent errors or reduce harm automatically; for example, parts that only fit one way, or mechanisms that cushion consequences. However, misuse is still possible during normal operation.

Examples
  • –A power drill with electronic brake, torque limiter, and insulated casing. These features reduce injury risk, but the operator can still slip or drill into something they shouldn't.
  • –A car with seatbelts and airbags. The safety systems help significantly in a crash, but reckless driving can still cause serious harm.
  • –An assisted-braking belay device, whether passive or active. The device helps catch a fall automatically, but incorrect technique can still cause the rope to slip through.
  • –A child car seat with ISOFIX connectors. The seat can only click into the correct anchor points, but the harness straps can still be adjusted too loosely.
  • –A gas cylinder regulator with a reverse thread fitting. The connector physically won't attach to the wrong gas type, but once connected the operator can still open the valve too fast or use incorrect pressure.
4

Fail-Safe

The device has designed-in mechanisms that enforce a safe state the operator cannot override during normal operation. Edge cases or external hazards may still exist, but the device's primary hazard is fully controlled.

Examples
  • –A microwave oven with redundant door interlocks. The magnetron physically cannot energise unless all switches confirm the door is sealed. The operator cannot run the microwave with the door open.
  • –A lift with door interlocks and slack-rope brakes. The car cannot move unless the doors are closed, and it will stop automatically if the cable fails.
  • –A climbing gym auto-belay. The device automatically takes up slack and arrests falls mechanically. The climber cannot override the braking system during normal use.
  • –A lawnmower with a two-hand operator presence control. The blade only runs while both hands grip the handles, so the operator cannot reach into the blade area during normal use.
5

Inherently Safe

The hazard has been designed out entirely. The device simply cannot cause serious harm through normal use.

Examples
  • –A plastic letter opener instead of a metal blade. It can open envelopes but cannot cut skin.
  • –Safety scissors with rounded tips. They can cut paper but cannot cut skin.

Quick Reference

Level Name What the device provides
0 No Protection No protection. Hazard fully exposed.
1 Safe Only With Correct Use No engineering controls. Safety depends on the operator.
2 Safety Encouraged Cues and warnings, but no enforcement.
3 Safety Assisted Designed to prevent errors or add automatic safety features, but misuse still possible.
4 Fail-Safe Enforced safe state. Cannot be overridden by operator.
5 Inherently Safe Hazard designed out. Cannot cause serious harm.